We believe that all women have stories to tell, and big dreams to achieve. 

Our empowering gifts are all women-made and support self-care, lift each other up, and remind you of all that you can do. 

Please note - due to Hurricane Ian, we are online-only and our orders take 2-3 weeks or more to fulfill from your order date. We are closing our shop and have featured sale items on our Instagram page @priscillasofsanibel - please check it out for latest sale updates! 

Why Choose Us?

We provide a variety of unique, handmade gifts made by women, for all ages from infants to adults. 

A portion of proceeds on all products go toward hurricane relief efforts with FISH of Sanibel and Captiva. 

Please note - due to Hurricane Ian, orders take 2-3 weeks or MORE to fulfill from your order date. Please do not reach out to us with order inquiries unless it has been a month from your order date. We understand that this timeline is not ideal 😊 Thanks for your patience!!! 

My Story


store owner

The store is named Priscilla’s after Priscilla Murphy, the first realtor on Sanibel Island. She traveled here from Michigan in the 1940s and opened up the first real estate office on the island in the early 1950s. She was my inspiration and muse - she is one of the many trailblazing women of Sanibel from past and present. 

My name is Maari and I live in Sanibel with my husband, Chas, and our children and dogs. We relocated here from Minnesota during the COVID-19 pandemic in August of 2020. After visiting here for my whole life, we decided to take a leap of faith and start a new adventure on the island of Sanibel. With a background in advertising/marketing, journalism and interior design and charity work in women advocacy groups, I feel that I have found my calling by opening Priscilla's of Sanibel. I am an old soul, inspired by the many women before us, and with us, who have worked so hard so that we can all enjoy this beautiful place on Earth. I am honored and humbled to be part of this wonderful community and I look forward to meeting you soon and hearing your own story. 


online only. 

No returns allowed at this time. Thanks for your understanding!

The Village Shops

2340 Periwinkle Way Unit F1 - Sanibel, FL


Monday - Saturday

10 am - 5 pm

Closed Sundays